Mining Disaster Coverage*

3:51 AM, January 4, 2006

The news cycle wasn't kind to papers east of the Mississippi last night. And I noticed that CNN didn't miss a chance to wave around the USA Today front with the outdated "12 miners survive" hed. Here's what some eastern papers look like this morning. (Note: It's possible some editions of these papers were updated after they made their front-page images for their web sites.)


charlestonbaltimore

bostonDC

atlantacolumbus


Those of us out West had a scramble, but got it in.


LAdenver

sjmnt.jpgstt.jpg

And here's how The Kansas City Star changed between editions.


kc

*Update: Atlanta's Kenny Monteith tells me that Journal-Constitution trucks and pressmen were called back in at 3 a.m. They printed a 23,000 run for street and convenience-store sales (below). The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette got an updated story into about 114,000 of their 256,000 press run.


ajcnewt.jpgPA_PPG106t.jpg

The Charleston Gazette called people back in and got out about 15,000 papers with a replate (below), and E&P says The Boston Globe managed to get the story into about 50,000 copies, and trashed 30,000 with the outdated headline.


cgnewt.jpgbgnewt.jpg

E&P also notes that the Philly Daily News had printed 120,000 copies with 30,000 to go when the word came, but kept printing "because a system shutdown for maintenance barred editors from changing the paper's content." Ouch. Looks like they, um, adjusted the version of the cover on the Daily News site, though.


pdnt.jpg

The 43,000-circulation Duluth News Tribune was able to remake Page One for more than half their papers, and other editors took to their web versions today to explain the outdated print versions.

*Update2: From this AP photo found at speigel.de by Jan Kny , it looks like the Daily News was able to update. The Post, not so much.


ny.jpg


Comments
Heads up: After you hit "post" things may be slow and you may get an error. Most likely, your comment did post. Apologies. I'm looking for a fix.

The Denver Post that arrived on my doorstop must have been an early edition... '12 of 13 miners found alive' with a different photo.

However, the Rocky Mountain News I received got it right despite the bad hed ('Joy short-lived'). The front linked on the left shows their initial stab at it.

After looking at Newseum this morning, I'm tempted to never use the word 'joy' in a hed again. It's too easy and most likely a bad generalization. I imagine a number of the family members and friends waiting there weren't going to be filled with joy until they saw someone come out of there alive. It was probably more gut-wrenching than anything to sit there for two days, waiting and getting conflicting news while still having no physical evidence of what's going on.

I hope "The Daily Show" will take a look at all the speculation the TV networks threw out; they'll be more than deserving after throwing around the early editions with the 'They're alive!' heds.

Posted by: Christopher Harrop at January 4, 2006 6:28 AM

I can't believe the KC star didn't change the photo. I wish I could read the caption.

Posted by: Scott at January 4, 2006 6:31 AM

Scott: I wasn't there when the Star changed the headline last night (and I wish the photo could've been changed) but that was a press issue no doubt. At the time they sent that page, they could've just got the story and black plate changed.

I'll have to find out the whole story when I get to work, but, that's usually all we can do after midnight.

gooch.

Posted by: gooch at January 4, 2006 7:04 AM

Scott: The Rocky also used one photo for the early and late editions, but considering they're a tab, I suppose it's apples and oranges.

Posted by: Christopher Harrop at January 4, 2006 8:32 AM

Ah yes, in this computer age I sometimes forget that things can't always be done instantly.

Posted by: Scott at January 4, 2006 8:54 AM

The caption on the second edition photo reflected the changing news: "Reacting to what turned out to be miscommunication Darlene Groves (left) and Crystina Neeling erupted in joy late Tuesday in Tallmansville, W.Va., Groves and Neeling are the sister-in-law and niece of miner Jerry Groves."

Posted by: Gooch at January 4, 2006 9:42 AM

Check out the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette ... they were the closest big paper to the accident. The paper I got at home this morning had it right.

Posted by: Bill at January 4, 2006 11:40 AM

Checking on TFP at Newseum, it seems like the smaller and quick-printing papers in the Central and Mountain time zones got hammered the hardest: They had time to update but the trucks were mainly gone and the newsrooms had cleared out when the jackholes in West Virginia finally said "um, well,...)

Many East Coast papers had versions of the story on the streets with outdated information but not the horrifically incorrect news.

And the West coast? Well, yet another reason for Neil Diamond to sing, "LA's fine, the sun shine's most the time, and the feeling is laid-back."

--C

Posted by: chris clonts at January 4, 2006 5:23 PM

Yeah, I was told we got the correct info on fully 2/3 of our papers in Colorado Springs. The only ones wrong: Those in stores and on racks. So, our subscribers are happy, but we didn't help ourselves with casual readers. D'oh.

Posted by: Ryan Ford at January 5, 2006 3:08 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?

































Home

About



Archives

Search

RSS 1.0 feed

RSS 2.0 feed