

I'm a bit behind on this, but London's Sunday Telegraph redesigned on Nov. 4, most notably ditching the old nameplate in favor of a Bodoni flag which Media Week says is reminiscent of the original 1960s style. The paper also shelved The Sunday Telegraph Magazine, replacing it with Stella, a women's magazine, and Seven, and arts and entertainment section.
Sarah Sands, The Sunday Telegraph's new editor, wrote an editor's note, which appears to be no longer online. BBC's Magazine Monitor summarized the note thusly:
» "I want to encourage intelligent writing, and to present it in an elegant fashion. I suppose you could call it brains and beauty."
» "'Seven' is the highest form of entertainment."
» "Our second magazine is 'Stella'. This is a journalistic spa: beautiful, calm, witty, transforming. If bathrooms have become modern temples, then 'Stella' is the pinnacle of bath time reading."
» "I want the Sunday Telegraph to be like your iPod - full of your favourite things."
» "Some Sunday papers are merely nasty habits. I hope you will buy the Sunday Telegraph because you love it..."
The scamps at Private Eye couldn't resist a send-up:
For me, a Sunday newspaper is like a bath bubble, floating in the air, smelling of perfume, with a picture of a woman in her knickers on the front page. And, just like a bath bubble, it should leave you transformed, fragrant, news-based and waspish. That's why you'll love our new magazine, 'Nutella' - it's creamy, chocolatey and easy to spread on your bread. Not to mention focusing on core news values around the world.In short, my dream is that the Sunday Gnomegraph is like an iPod - full of old rubbish that you don't want to listen to.
"Papers that don't have to worry about making profits are starting from a different logic."If you're doing what's basically vanity publishing, you can do it in whatever shape you like. Commercially it makes sense to be broadsheet. Advertisers don't like tabloids — it is a fashion."
More pages after the jump.
Immediate gut reaction: I find myself liking the old one better. Those rules in the new one are way too thick, and the logo has no personality at all. The magazine needs help - the random column widths in the 'I Spy' spread are painful.
(I feel bad for the cartoonist in the lower left on the new front page: time was when you could get a tabloid page all to yourself.)
Posted by: Brakhage at November 16, 2005 8:14 AMMy thought is that it's a bit hit-and-miss. Some of it is excellent, like the better play of the reefers on the front page. They draw attention without completely dominating the page.
But I wonder about the new nameplates -- are the colors always based on the page? Clearly I don't know enough about the Telegraph, but it seems like a gamble. And while I haven't seen the old magazine's inside pages, or Stella, the new magazines don't have the visual drama they should.
If anything, the redesign looks like a step to the side.
Posted by: Nic at November 16, 2005 10:26 AMi don’t know much about the sunday telegraph... all that I can say is that the world of newspaper design is turning to order, hierarchy, navigation and simplicity...
sorry, but this redesign goes exactly in the opposite direction.
Posted by: Zork at November 16, 2005 11:29 AMI agree that the outgoing nameplate had lots more character. After reading that the ST traditionally used a modern nameplate, the choice makes a little more sense, but the new one's flavorless.
I don't get why some newspapers ditched in the last 20-25 years their classic nameplates for modern-looking pieces of garbage... only to go back to the classic look, realizing they didn't wear well and didn't have gravitas to begin with.
Posted by: Douglas E. at November 16, 2005 11:49 AMIs it just me or does the new design look more like a web site than a newspaper?
Posted by: Mike C at November 17, 2005 6:19 AMNever mind the redesign itself - kudos to Mark for the best rock-song reference in a headline on the site yet! (And from a quintessentially British band, no less...)
Posted by: Scott Fybush at November 21, 2005 4:17 PMI find it amazing that they still haven't found the time to update the logos on their website.
Posted by: Alexander at November 28, 2005 3:35 PM