THE DALLAS MORNING NEWS AND THE BERG PHOTOS

11:36 PM, May 12, 2004

TX_DMN512t.jpg
On Wednesday's front page, the Dallas Morning News ran no photos with the Nick Berg execution story other than a mugshot. Looks a bit like their editorial board disagreed with that call, and on Thursday's editorial page will run a photo of a terrorist holding up Berg's severed head. The head is obscured by a black box.

The editorial with the photo gives this explanation:

Presenting this photograph, which was taken from an al-Qaeda-affiliated Web site, is important because of the power of image to shape public opinion. Shocking photographs have driven the Abu Ghraib prison atrocity story, which has now become a national crisis of confidence in this nation's civilian and military leadership, and the mission in Iraq. If we show you images of Abu Ghraib abuses, and of soldiers' coffins at Dover Air Force base because we think you should know the truth about this war, then we should show you this image, too.
Editorial writer Rod Dreher pushed to run the photo, and on the editorial board's weblog he sounds much the same note:
I proposed this morning that we run the image of the terrorist brandishing the severed head, but blur the face on the head, for this reason alone: to remind readers what kind of enemy we're up against. The photos from Abu Ghraib provoked a national spasm of soul-searching, and many in this country are suffering in turn from a loss of confidence in American leadership, and the mission in Iraq. I am not opposed to those photos being released. But I think we owe it to the public to tell the other side of the story.
And, on CNN's NewsNight, Editorial Page Editor Keven Willey said:
We had considered digitizing it much as television does. We looked at that image and even that we felt was borderline gruesome. It didn't quite -- we decided in the beginning that, if we were going to do this, we wanted to do it in a responsible way and stick to some narrow principles. And we felt that the -- digitizing it didn't quite achieve that. And that's why we went with this particular route.
CNN, incidentally, did not show the photo, although Aaron Brown indicated he thought they should.

>This is the Enemy: Vile image shows world why we fight [Dallas Morning News]
>Should DMN show the beheading? [DMN Daily]
>NewsNight with Aaron Brown [CNN]


Comments
Heads up: After you hit "post" things may be slow and you may get an error. Most likely, your comment did post. Apologies. I'm looking for a fix.

Seems the Denver Post is not alone in those horrible doglegs.

Posted by: Paul Wiggins at May 13, 2004 4:56 PM

I think you should show the photos and video of beheading, just to show the public how in human people can be and show realism to the world we live in, the only reason i would think of not showing the photos is out of respect for the family of Nick Berg, but nobody has any respect for serious issues like this anymore anyway.

Posted by: Desiree' Shields at May 20, 2004 4:24 PM

People! Are goverment runs our people on fear!
tell me that the people behind the black hoods are
our own goverment or who knows? Me Myself do-not trust our U.S. goverment(german mafia hoods)The abuse of prisoner's oversea happen's to our own american's in our prison right here in the U.S.
SLAVE LABOR CAMPS RIGHT IN THE MOTHERLAND OF THE U.S.A. NEXT TIME YOU PUT ON A PAIR OF RED WIND BOOTS REMAMBER THAT SLAVE CAMPS OF THE U.S.A. AMERICAN MADE THEM FOR $25 cents per hour!AMERICAN FREEDOM FIGHT FOR IT OR LOOSE IT TO BUSH OIL!WITH OUR AMERICAN BLOOD!

Posted by: robert jenkins at May 22, 2004 5:38 PM

my prayers go out to the family.

thank you tammy

Posted by: tammy witten at May 22, 2004 10:34 PM

For your article on the President Bush speech, I would look more on the positive side of things. After all wouldn't the Dallas, TEXAS newspaper be aiming that way?!

Posted by: AP at September 4, 2004 12:05 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?

































Home

About



Archives

Search

RSS 1.0 feed

RSS 2.0 feed